Daily Religion Column

More on Daily Religion

Sita - 

Versions vary; values do not-II

As we saw, Kamban's Sita stood there on the balcony of the gynaecium of Mithila and Rama was passing the streets of the city along with his brother and Viswamitra. Rama looked up and Sita looked down accidentally and their eyes met. The two gazed and gazed at each other and fell in love, even before Sri Rama entered the court of Janaka, leave alone lifting the bow up and stringing it.

Though very minor, this one is an important detour that Kamban made, which has many sociological aspects to consider. We examined some of them. (See: 'pEsavum vENdumO?' and If it is not he)

'Katradhu Tamizh' Ram's next
Diwali in Suburbs
Rajini Still In A Dilemma!
அஜீத் பேட்டி?
ராம் இயக்கத்தில் சேரன்?
கமல் பாராட்டிய டைட்டில்

We are not speaking about the 'Thai' version and other varied versions of the Ramayana prevailing in several other countries. Most of them would make an ardent devotee of Ramayana to throw his hands up in sheer desperation, at the unbelievable twists and turns that the story takes, moving completely away from the main line as it is known in India.

If there were three versions of the Ramayana in Sanskrit, there was a version of the Ramayana in Tamil before Kamban attempted his monumental work. This version is not available now. Even the name of the author is unknown. But, that it existed is evidenced by the pieces of quotations from that earlier version, cited as explanatory notes by stalwarts like Nachinaarikiniyar, in his commentary on Tholkaapiyam and other ancient classics in Tamil. And it is by sheer accident that pieces of this rich treasure are preserved by commentators, who quoted a small portion to explain some other context in another story or a sutra in a book like Tolkappiyam.

One such piece says, 'aaL vinai mudiththa arundhava munivan'. The sage after completing his yaga (meaning Viswamitra), 'vELvi pOtriya iraaman avanodu,' along with Rama, who stood guard at the time of yaga, 'mithilai mUdhUr eydhiya gnaandrai,' entered the ancient town of Mithila. And when he did so, 'madhi udam patta madak kaN seethai...' Sita fell in love with him.

This piece of an ancient version of Ramayana in Tamil, that must have existed at least a 1500-2000 years before Kamban, found by sheer accident in the most unexpected place - in the midst of a long commentary on a sutra - gives a very vital clue as to why Kamban depicted the divine couple as falling in love even before Rama was taken to the bow, (See: aNNalum nOkkinaan avaLum nOkkinaaL)

But the fact remains that Valmiki portrayed the wedding of the divine couple in a particular way and the portrayal of Kamban adds a shade more to the original. If the two poets painted their pictures differently, one strong reason behind such change is the tradition of the particular area in which the heart of the poet sprouted.

Well, that is one of the aspects that we have been pursuing thus far, looking at the finer details of construction of events in the story and how it affects the characterisation and the architectonics as a whole.

Most important of all - We have been looking at the story, as Right Hon'ble Srinivasa Sastriyar put it, "as a human story, lived among human beings by a human being,' and as he pointed out, we do realise the "rich treasures there are of wisdom in it." Versions may vary. Values do not.

With this background, my dear friends, let us get back to mother Sita from where we left her in the Sundara Kanda, speaking to Hanuman, giving out her message to her Lord and to Lakshmana and asking him to stay over in the Asoka Vana until it was dawn, for his presence was nothing but manna for her lacerated heart.

Continued from last instalment

Next


Recommend this page

Mail us your feedback

More follows...

Hari Krishnan
Author's website on Tamil Literature
http://www.harimozhi.com

More on Daily Religion

Published on Mach 10th, 2005

Post your ads for FREE!

Online Homeopathy Consulting!
BSE/NSE Live
Find ur home at IndiaProperty
Real Estate In India
Horoscope with 10 Year's Prediction
Copyright © 2010, Chennai Interactive Business Services (P) Ltd. All rights reserved.
Phone: 91-44-52024601; 52071942; 52071943. Fax: 91-44-52122754
cibs@chennaionline.com - Copyright and Disclaimer - Privacy Policy